HorrorFam.com is bringing back the local video rental store vibe! Each of our writers is chooses one horror movie per month they recommend you watch. Just like the “employees’ picks” video shelf from back in the day – it’s super fun for us, and it helps you get to know which of our writers’ tastes most align with your own, so you can get extra excited on Fridays when they have a new article or review go live!
Streaming, renting, or buying a film we suggest via using our JustWatch affiliate buttons is also a perfect way to support the content and people you love here at HorrorFam.com at zero additional cost to you. It keeps HorrorFam.com ad-free and focused on what matters most: YOU and your enjoyment of horror! We’re 100% reader/watcher supported. Thank you, from all of us.
Looking for horror films for tweens & teens specifically? We’ve got that covered too!
HorrorFam.com’s Faves for May 2025 Horror Movies Streaming Now
Read On Below or Jump To...
Lauren Spear’s Pick
Where to Watch The Frighteners (1996):
Frank Spear’s Pick
Where to Watch Late Night with the Devil (2024):
Christi Bandy’s Pick
Where to Watch Heart Eyes (2025):
Isaiah Swanson’s Pick
Where to Watch The Ugly Stepsister (2025):
AJ Spencer’s Pick
Where to Watch Cheater Cheater (2024):
Robert Tharp’s Pick
Where to Watch Abbott & Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948):
Cathy Tharp’s Pick
Note: Lauren’s mom doesn’t write articles for HorrorFam.com, but she’s an important cheerleader behind-the-scenes and wanted to contribute to this page!
Where to Watch Bone Eater (2008):
Heather Landry/SandpaperDaisy’s Pick
Where to Watch The Thing (1982):
The Top 3 Horror Films Streaming Online for May 2025:
#1 Companion
Where to Watch Companion (2025):
#2 The Substance
Where to Watch The Substance (2024):
#3 The Monkey
Where to Watch The Monkey (2025):
Thank you for supporting HorrorFam.com! We update every single Friday with new articles and reviews – and you can come back to this page for our latest pick-of-the-month.
Images for this page were purchased via MovieStillsDB and CineMaterial.